The legal battle over Beyoncé’s stolen music has come to a swift conclusion after the man responsible accepted a last-minute plea deal to avoid a lengthy trial. Kelvin Evans pleaded guilty on Tuesday, May 12, 2026, to multiple charges stemming from a high-profile theft that occurred just days before the Atlanta leg of the record-breaking Cowboy Carter tour last summer. The case, which has drawn international attention from the music industry and fans alike, highlights the growing security challenges faced by major global productions in the digital age.
The incident took place in early July 2025 inside a parking deck at Krog Street Market in Atlanta. Surveillance footage captured Evans breaking into a rented black Jeep Wagoneer used by a member of Beyoncé's creative team, specifically her choreographer Christopher Grant and a lead dancer. According to a police report obtained by WXIA-TV, the thief shattered the back lift gate and made off with two suitcases containing personal items and, more importantly, several high-capacity hard drives. These drives contained watermarked unreleased tracks, footage, plans for the upcoming stadium show, and highly sensitive archival and future set lists that were central to the tour's visual and musical identity.
While the theft initially sparked fears of a catastrophic online leak, investigators were able to act quickly. Using a combination of the "Find My" app to track stolen AirPods and the city's extensive network of Flock license plate cameras, police identified a silver vehicle linked to the crime. Kelvin Evans, who was 40 at the time of the theft, was eventually implicated not just in this high-stakes burglary but in a wider string of vehicle break-ins across the Fulton County area. According to a report by the Associated Press, prosecutors argued that the suspect was part of an organized effort targeting luxury vehicles in high-traffic commercial zones.
Evans had initially maintained his innocence throughout the early months of 2026, even rejecting a five-year plea offer that was presented in March. However, facing a potential six-year prison sentence and a mountain of digital and physical evidence, he opted for an 11th-hour deal. Appearing via video before the Fulton County Superior Court, Evans admitted to charges of entering auto and criminal trespass.
Reflecting on the nature of the crime during the proceedings, a representative for the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office stated, "This was not a random act of opportunity, but a calculated theft of intellectual property that had the potential to derail a global cultural moment." Senior Judge Jane C. Barwick sentenced him to a total of five years, with the first two years to be served in prison and the remainder on probation. As part of the conditions for his release, the judge ordered Evans to stay away from the Krog Street location and have no contact with the victims.
This case has served as a wake-up call for the live entertainment industry, which saw record-high global grosses in 2024 and 2025. The transition to the Cowboy Carter era was marked by an unprecedented level of secrecy, and the temporary loss of this data posed a significant risk to the artistic rollout of the project. Industry experts note that the security of digital assets has now become as important as physical stage security for top-tier artists. Following the incident, security analysts at Billboard noted that Beyoncé’s production team reportedly overhauled their data handling procedures, requiring encrypted cloud-based backups and banning the transport of master drives in non-secure vehicles. "The industry must treat digital masters with the same level of protection as armored cars treat currency," one analyst remarked.
While the unreleased music was reportedly recovered before it could be sold to collectors or leaked to the public, the legal precedent remains clear. The sentencing of Evans signals that the legal system is increasingly prepared to treat the theft of digital creative property with the same severity as physical assets.