The legal proceedings against former Henrico Doctors’ Hospital nurse Erin Elizabeth Ann Strotman reached a significant milestone on January 15, 2026, when a judge found her guilty of nine felony charges of child abuse following her no-contest plea. This conviction addresses a series of horrific incidents occurring between 2022 and 2024, during which nine premature infants in the hospital’s neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) suffered unexplainable bone fractures and severe bruising.
Strotman’s actions first drew major scrutiny in late 2024 after hospital surveillance captured her using what investigators described as "dangerous" and "forceful" maneuvers on fragile infants. In one particularly disturbing video from November 10, 2024, Strotman was allegedly seen pushing a five-month-old infant's legs back until his feet reached his head, resulting in fractures to his ribs and legs.
According to a criminal complaint detailed by 8News, the nurse was also seen "placing her weight down on the legs" of a baby who appeared to be "crying in distress." While Strotman initially claimed to police, "I just feel like I was doing what I was taught to do," medical experts and prosecutors emphasized that her behavior was entirely inconsistent with acceptable standards of nursing care.
Her defense attorneys later admitted that "she probably caused some of these injuries, if not all of them," though they maintained she never intended to harm the children. One grieving father, Dominique Hackey, shared the emotional toll of the discovery with Fox News Digital, stating, "My son knew pain before he knew any type of happiness, any type of joy, anything."
The investigation revealed that the abuse reportedly ceased during a period in 2023 when Strotman was placed on administrative leave following an initial internal hospital review into mysterious fractures, but the injuries resumed shortly after she was allowed to return to duty in late 2024.
This timeline has raised significant questions regarding institutional oversight and the hospital's failure to prevent further harm after the initial red flags were raised in 2023. As part of the negotiated plea deal, Strotman is permanently barred from ever practicing as a nurse again or working in any capacity with children. Court documents filed by the Henrico Commonwealth’s Attorney further clarify that the defendant's nursing license was officially revoked to prevent any future access to vulnerable patients.
However, some legal analysts and community members have expressed skepticism regarding the adequacy of the plea agreement, questioning whether a maximum seek of three years' incarceration is sufficient for crimes involving nine vulnerable victims. Skeptics argue that by dropping the more severe "malicious wounding" charges, the prosecution may have prioritized a guaranteed conviction over a sentence that reflects the lifelong physical and developmental risks these infants now face.
Legal experts speaking to the Richmond Times-Dispatch suggested that a trial would have been a high-stakes gamble for both sides, leading to the eventual compromise. There are concerns that such a deal might not provide a strong enough deterrent for future medical misconduct, especially given that the infants were unable to advocate for themselves or report the abuse as it happened.
Furthermore, the case has highlighted potential systemic failures in how medical facilities monitor staff in high-stakes environments like the NICU. Health department officials noted that the gap between the initial 2023 injuries and Strotman's eventual arrest in late 2024 suggests that the hospital's internal "buddy-observer" and reporting systems were either bypassed or insufficient.
The fact that a single individual could cause such extensive physical trauma over a two-year period without immediate intervention has sparked a broader debate about the necessity of mandatory, real-time remote monitoring by third-party security firms rather than internal staff. Advocates from the Patient Safety Foundation have pointed to this case as a prime example of why hospitals need independent oversight. Families of the victims continue to push for new legislation that would mandate 24/7 accessible video feeds for parents of hospitalized minors.
Although the former nurse originally faced nearly two dozen charges, including malicious wounding and child neglect, the plea agreement streamlined the case toward a sentencing hearing scheduled for June 5, 2026, at 11:00 a.m.
Each felony child abuse charge carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison, and the upcoming hearing will allow the nine affected families to deliver victim impact statements that will likely influence the final duration of her incarceration.
As the community awaits the final sentencing, the case continues to serve as a catalyst for stricter surveillance and reporting mandates within neonatal care facilities nationwide to ensure such a breach of trust never occurs again.