Minnesota Election Judge Pleads Guilty to Allowing Unregistered Voters to Cast Ballots

Timothy Michael Scouton, a 65-year-old head election judge in Hubbard County, pleaded guilty on Monday, March 23, 2026, to a felony charge of accepting the vote of an unregistered voter.

The plea stems from an incident during the November 2024 general election at the Badoura Township precinct, where Scouton reportedly bypassed state law by allowing 11 individuals to vote without completing required same-day registration forms.

The case has drawn significant national attention after being highlighted by prominent social media accounts as a flashpoint for election integrity concerns in Governor Tim Walz’s Minnesota.

According to court records, Scouton instructed the unregistered voters to simply sign the back of a registration book rather than following the legally mandated registration process.

While originally facing two felony counts, the second charge of neglect of duty by an election official was dismissed as part of the plea agreement.

Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon’s office confirmed that the discrepancy was identified immediately through standard post-election audits and noted that Scouton "made a conscious decision to disregard state law."

Despite the social media firestorm, officials emphasized that the incident occurred in a small rural precinct and there is no evidence that the 11 ballots impacted the outcome of any local or national races.

The swift identification of the error is being cited by state authorities as proof that the state's election security protocols are functioning as intended.

Scouton is currently scheduled for sentencing on May 18, 2026. The case continues to serve as a catalyst for broader political debates regarding the vulnerability of the voting process and the oversight of poll workers.

While critics argue the incident proves systemic flaws in the region's election management, proponents of the current system point to the felony prosecution as a clear message that election interference even on a minor scale will be met with severe legal consequences.