She blamed vaccines for her twins' deaths. Now police say she killed them.
Idaho mother Andrea Shaw, 23, faces two counts of first-degree murder more than a year after her toddlers were found dead in their bed.
When two babies die, a mother’s grief is supposed to be sacred. But sometimes, the stories we hear hide a much darker truth.
In May 2025, police found twin toddlers dead in their shared bed in Payette, Idaho. Days later, their mother, Andrea Shaw, went on a podcast. She claimed three routine shots killed her children.
For over a year, police quietly looked into the case. Now, a grand jury has charged the 23-year-old mother with murder.
Officers found and arrested Shaw in Boise on June 30. They charged her with two counts of first-degree murder.
Key Facts
- May 1, 2025: Twin toddlers found dead in a shared bed in Payette, Idaho.
- 23: Age of the mother, Andrea Shaw, who blamed vaccines for the deaths.
- 3: Number of vaccines Shaw claimed killed her babies on a podcast.
- 1: Over one year of police work before charges were filed.
- 2: Counts of first-degree murder Shaw now faces.
Get help from someone local. Text HELP to (805) 719-7630 and we'll set up a time to talk that works for you.
Why It Matters
This case shows how easily a sad event can be used to spread fear. The mother's story spread on anti-vaccine channels, fueling doubts about public health. Now, those claims face a murder charge in court.
It reminds us to wait for facts before we believe stories online. A community's trust was used to push a message that police now say was a cover-up.
What Happens Next
Shaw is in jail in Boise. She is waiting to go back to Payette, where she will face a judge for her first court hearing.
The medical examiner has not yet shared the official cause of death with the public. Those details will likely come out during her trial.
What We Still Don't Know
- What was the physical cause of death for the twins?
- What specific evidence led the grand jury to charge the mother with murder?
- How will the group that hosted her podcast respond to her arrest?