Security cameras catch the same man walking into the store with an empty bag and walking out with a fortune in steak, leaving honest shoppers to pay the price for a system that keeps opening its doors.
WHAT HAPPENED James Stafford has turned the Charlotte Food Lion into his personal pantry. The 64 year old man was caught on video walking into the store with a rolling suitcase, filling it to the brim with expensive meat, and simply strolling out the front door.
Local records show this is not a one-time mistake. Stafford has been arrested 15 times and has faced over 40 criminal charges for his brazen thefts. Even though he is caught repeatedly, the local justice system has allowed him to walk free after every single arrest.
Right now, Stafford is back on the street. He is currently out on bond for four different theft charges he picked up just this year. He continues to target the same grocery chain while he waits for his next date in court.
What the evidence shows
15: The total number of times Stafford has been arrested by local police.
- 40+: The number of criminal charges piled up against him over the years.
- 4: The number of new larceny cases he has already started in 2026.
- 100%: The rate at which he has been released on bond after his arrests.
- $0: The amount Stafford paid for the suitcases of meat seen on video.
THE BIGGER QUESTION When does a "second chance" become a green light for a crime wave? Every time Stafford is let out on bond, he goes right back to the same grocery aisles with the same suitcase. We have to ask why the court system keeps releasing a man who has proven 15 times that he will not follow the law while he is out.
THE OTHER SIDE Legal advocates for bond reform argue that people should not stay in jail for non-violent crimes like shoplifting while they wait for trial. they claim that keeping someone behind bars for stealing food is a waste of taxpayer money and that Stafford likely needs social services rather than a prison cell. This argument appears weak to many local business owners who say the lack of consequences is making the city unsafe for retail.
WHAT HAPPENS NOW Stafford is currently free as he awaits trial for his most recent string of thefts. Food Lion staff are on high alert, but company policy often stops workers from stepping in to block the door during a theft. This means prices may go up for everyone else to cover the cost of the "suitcase meat" that keeps walking out the door.
WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
- Why has a judge not set a higher bond given his 15 prior arrests?
- Is Stafford selling the stolen meat to other people or using it himself?
- How much total money has the Food Lion chain lost to this one man?
SOURCE NOTE Information from Charlotte-Mecklenburg case files and store surveillance footage. All charges are allegations. James Stafford is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.