A man allegedly killed his wife and then used her ring to propose to a new date

Aaron Nelson is accused of hiding his wife's body and moving on with a new partner just weeks after she went missing.

It is hard to imagine a deeper betrayal than the one described by police in Wisconsin this week. A husband is accused of ending his wife's life and then using her own wedding ring to start a new relationship.

What Happened

Alexis Nelson vanished in March 2025. She and her husband, 43-year-old Aaron Nelson, were last seen together on security cameras at a store in Beaver Dam.

Shortly after she disappeared, Aaron Nelson reportedly changed his Facebook status to "widowed." He then met a new woman on Tinder in April. By May, the two were living together.

Police eventually tracked down the new girlfriend. They noticed she was wearing an engagement ring that matched the one belonging to the missing wife.

What the money/evidence shows

• Alexis Nelson has been missing since March 29, 2025.
• Aaron Nelson bought a 32-gallon trash can shortly after his wife disappeared.
• Police found that same trash can at the home of his new fiancée.
• The trash can tested positive for the blood of Alexis Nelson.
• A cadaver dog found the scent of human remains in a shed on the property.

The Bigger Question

How does someone move so quickly from a marriage to a new life while a body is still hidden? We often look for signs of guilt in the way people act after a crime.

But this case forces us to ask if we are paying enough attention to the people around us. Could a neighbor or a friend have seen the red flags before it was too late?

The Other Side

Aaron Nelson is currently held on a $1 million cash bond. His legal team has not yet provided a public statement regarding the specific evidence found by police. The strength of the state's case will likely hinge on the forensic results from the trash can and the shed.

What Happens Now

Aaron Nelson is scheduled to return to court on May 28. The search for the remains of Alexis Nelson continues as the legal process moves forward.

This case serves as a grim reminder of the dangers hidden behind closed doors. It also highlights the work local police must do to find justice when a body is never recovered.

What We Still Don't Know

• Where are the remains of Alexis Nelson located?
• Did anyone else know about the trash can or the shed before the police arrived?
• What was the specific motive behind the killing of his wife?

SOURCE NOTE

: All charges are allegations - Aaron Nelson is presumed innocent until proven guilty.*